Is Financial Inclusion a Scam?

The following two tabs change content below.

James Shepherd-Barron

Disaster Management Consultant, Disaster Epidemiologist, Author, and Founder of The Aid Workers Union

Latest posts by James Shepherd-Barron (see all)

SUMMARY: There is growing evidence that the wholesale move to digital payments advocated for by fintech lobbyists is not the techno-utopian panacea that its proponents proclaim. In fact, far from its stated aim of fostering financial inclusion, evidence from Kenya, India and elsewhere demonstrates that it actually excludes the most vulnerable in society by fostering indebtedness and preventing them from using their preferred, and often only, means of payment … cash. The international aid community should be more critical of the costs and compulsions involved with going ‘cashless’ and realise that restriction of payment options is neither a plausible nor appropriate way of achieving the ends they seek … that is, suppressing cash will not make the poor better off.

The financial inclusion movement argues that the poor are desperately in need of a whole range of market-driven financial instruments in order to better cope with what is often referred to as “the predicament of their poverty.” At the heart of their strategy lies the claim that reducing payment options by banning cash – the direct and intended consequence of fintech digitisation – will benefit the poor by promoting access to a range of financial products and services such as loans and insurance.

Unfortunately, the debate over the real value of digital transformation in the financial services sector in low and middle-income countries is hopelessly one-sided since it is the fintech lobby itself that is leading it.

There is no doubt that fintech has the potential to liberate enormous value that could make the lives of the global poor immeasurably better. But the bulk of value being released by fintech does not appear to be designed for their benefit. Instead it flows upwards into the hands of a narrow global financial-digital elite that are the main forces behind the fintech revolution.

Applying their more ‘Wilsonian’ principles, the larger American NGOs such as Mercy Corps, Care International and the International Rescue Committee seem to have become part of this elite and are now, accordingly, selling us the myth that eliminating cash lowers costs while stimulating small and medium enterprise among the poor. In reality, as case study after case study from India and Africa has shown, cash is the least expensive payment option and its elimination actually reduces opportunities for entrepreneurship among people of limited means while stimulating indebtedness.

Consider the fact that money supply in India has grown by 13% since ‘de-monetisation’ or the serious gambling problem currently afflicting Kenya and its neighbouring countries of Rwanda, Uganda and Tanzania where conventional micro-credit aggressively sold through mobile phone apps have already begun to create worrying levels of personal debt. The arrival of fintech has clearly begun to exacerbate this problem. Even one-time micro-credit advocates such as Graham Wright, founder and Managing Director of Microsave, one of Africa’s most successful financial inclusion consultancy companies, are now sounding the alarm.

Given the evidence now available, aid agencies continue to wittingly or unwittingly connive in passing fees and commissions to an industry that accentuates financial inequity, doesn’t pay its fair share of taxes, and doesn’t stimulate the economy.

At the centre of this transformation lies the UN-facilitated Better Than Cash Alliance (BTCA), a group of NGOs, governments, donors, UN agencies, private sector financial institutions and silicon valley philanthrocapitalists dedicated to the overthrow of the cash economy.  The BTCA personifies the self-interest of this narrow elite, “quietly doing their bidding while presenting themselves to the world as if they are really all about helping the global poor when what they are actually doing is promoting an ideological, market-driven form of financial intermediation which benefits mostly American multinationals” as Milford Bateman, a visiting Professor of Economics at the University of Pula, puts it.

He seems to have a point. It’s certainly very hard to find anywhere in the BTCA’s online marketing materials any reference to the downsides of this approach. Instead, the literature, most of it funded by vested interests, is permeated by the idea that promoting the growth of digital payments justifies the means of forcibly restricting the use of cash.

The movement towards digitisation and away from cash has proven a boon for payments companies such as Visa and Mastercard whose share prices have risen more than 1,000 percent over the past decade, more than double the IT Index and triple the S&P 500. Financial Institutions such as Citibank, Visa, and MasterCard – together with the Telecommunications Companies that work with them – support the BTCA for obvious reasons: In a cash-free world, these corporations not only make profits on the front-end by selling electronic payment devices and charging a fee for every transaction, but also make money on the back-end by compelling everyone to deposit their savings with them.

Slowly, we are waking up to the fact that the digital transformation, while bringing significant opportunities, has tended to exacerbate inequality and accelerate the centralisation of power. In effect, it is privatising what for centuries has been a common good. This means it comes with significant risks and the potential for unintended consequences. One of these is taxation. Fans of the cashless society argue that one of the benefits of the digital transformation is that it increases income and sales tax revenues. Indeed, it does. But this increase is overwhelmingly and disproportionately paid by the poor. Such consequences need to be mitigated.

We We have to hope that genuinely non-governmental organisations and international development agencies are open to the argument that the restriction of payment options is neither a plausible nor appropriate way of achieving the ends they seek … that is, suppressing cash will not make the poor better off. The BTCA – including its government members, therefore – seems not to consider this possibility. Transition to digital payments is treated uncritically as a good thing without due consideration being given to the costs or compulsions involved.

Thus, what appears to be well-intentioned ‘do-gooding’ seems to have become an accomplice to a greater, if less visible, harm which keeps alternative pro-poor development models off the table while providing a whole array of ideological and financial gains for global elites under the smokescreen of ‘financial inclusion’.

Meanwhile, the BTCA claims that they cashless society would enable the poor to participate fully in the financial system. In reality, it will compel those currently un-banked into the formal financial system which, as the situation in Kenya shows, opens them up in turn to further indebtedness. In this, the BTCA’s agenda poses a real threat to their individual and economic liberty.

With cautions like these in mind, those who are genuinely committed to poverty reduction and social justice should be more critical of financial digitalisation and should ensure that they have properly taken into account the short, medium, and long-term consequences of the various transfer modalities and payments systems on offer.

End

©James Shepherd-Barron

For further information, contact the author on [email protected]

Leave a comment